I’m sitting in the living room trying to enjoy a quiet Saturday afternoon when I notice Mr Whiskers watching me from the windowsill. Pandora is out running errands, John Mercer is in his room, and the house is unusually peaceful. Under normal circumstances, I would consider this an ideal opportunity to relax, particularly after yesterday’s conversation with Pandora about my tendency to turn ordinary household activities into investigations. I promised her I would make an effort to stop analyzing every little thing, and I fully intend to honor that commitment. Unfortunately, Mr Whiskers appears to have other plans. He is sitting perfectly still with his front paws tucked neatly beneath him, staring at me with an expression I can only describe as deliberate. I look at him, then back at my book, but when I glance up again, he hasn’t moved. I tell myself that cats stare at things all the time and that there is absolutely no reason to interpret his behavior as meaningful. Nevertheless, after several minutes of being watched, I begin to feel that I am participating in something without having agreed to it.
I decide to test whether Mr Whiskers is actually watching me or simply looking in my general direction. I shift slightly to the left on the couch, and his eyes follow me. I lean to the right, and his head turns. I stand up, and he immediately sits upright, his ears pointing forward as though he has been waiting for this exact moment. This is not especially reassuring. I walk toward the kitchen, and he jumps down from the windowsill and follows me. When I stop, he stops. When I turn around, he sits down and looks up at me. I remind myself that this is perfectly normal behavior for a cat, particularly one who has successfully trained the household to respond to his demands for food. Yesterday he managed to obtain an extra treat simply by meowing at the cupboard, and I am beginning to suspect that his recent successes have encouraged him to experiment with more sophisticated methods of persuasion. I tell him that I am not going to investigate anything today. He blinks slowly, which I choose to interpret as acknowledgment rather than disagreement.
John comes out of his room a few minutes later and finds me standing in the hallway with Mr Whiskers sitting approximately three feet away. He asks why I’m staring at the cat. I explain that I’m not staring at him; I’m determining whether he is following me. John looks at the cat, then at me, and says, “He’s probably hoping you’ll feed him.” I tell him Mr Whiskers has already eaten and that his food bowl is currently empty only because he finished his breakfast. John says, “Then he wants more.” I explain that while this is a plausible explanation, it does not account for the intensity of his attention. John asks whether I have considered that the cat might simply like me. I admit the possibility has occurred to me, although Mr Whiskers generally expresses affection by rubbing against someone’s legs or climbing onto their lap, not by maintaining prolonged eye contact from across the room. John tells me I should be flattered. I tell him I would be considerably more flattered if the cat’s attention didn’t make me feel as though I had failed to complete an assignment. John laughs and returns to his room, leaving me alone with an animal who has still not looked away.
I return to the living room and make a deliberate effort to ignore Mr Whiskers. I sit down, open my book, and begin reading the same paragraph I have already attempted three times. Within a minute, I hear a soft thump as the cat jumps onto the couch beside me. He walks across the cushion, places one paw on my leg, and meows. I scratch him behind the ears, but he doesn’t settle down. Instead, he jumps off the couch, walks toward the hallway, and looks back at me. I remain seated. He meows again. I tell him that I understand he wants something, but I am not going to participate in another elaborate household investigation merely because he has decided to communicate through a series of increasingly theatrical gestures. He waits for several seconds, then returns to the couch and places both front paws on my knee. I look down at him. He looks up at me. I tell him this is precisely the kind of behavior that caused yesterday’s discussion with Pandora. He meows again, apparently unconcerned about the state of my relationship or my recent commitment to personal improvement.
Eventually, I get up and follow him into the kitchen, not because I am investigating anything, but because I would like to determine whether he needs something that falls within the ordinary responsibilities of pet ownership. Mr Whiskers walks directly to the cupboard where we keep his treats and sits down. I explain that he already received treats yesterday and that I am not going to reward him every time he leads me into the kitchen. He looks at the cupboard, then at me, then back at the cupboard. I tell him this is not a negotiation. He responds by standing on his hind legs and placing one paw against the cabinet door. I remind him that Pandora specifically asked me to stop getting distracted by these little incidents, and I have every intention of demonstrating that I can maintain reasonable boundaries. He lowers himself to the floor and sits down again. For several seconds we remain in this position, each apparently waiting for the other to reconsider. Then Mr Whiskers walks away, and I feel a small but satisfying sense of accomplishment. I have successfully resisted an attempt at manipulation by a domestic animal.
At work the previous day, Karen had mentioned that setting boundaries sometimes means accepting that other people will be disappointed. She was talking about something entirely unrelated to cats, but the principle seems applicable. I remember telling Dave about Pandora’s request that I spend less time investigating household mysteries, and he had laughed before asking whether I thought I could manage an entire weekend without examining something suspicious. I assured him I could. He said he would believe it when he saw it, which struck me as unnecessarily skeptical. Standing in the kitchen now, I feel I have demonstrated precisely the restraint everyone has been encouraging. I return to the living room, sit down, and open my book again. Mr Whiskers follows me but does not approach. Instead, he sits on the floor several feet away and watches me with what appears to be mild disappointment. I decide that his emotional response is not my responsibility. This is a significant development in my personal growth, and I intend to enjoy it.
About twenty minutes later, I hear a scratching sound coming from the hallway. I look up and see Mr Whiskers standing beside the closet door, pawing at the bottom. This is unusual because he has never shown much interest in that closet, which contains coats, shoes, and a few miscellaneous household items. I watch him for a moment before reminding myself that cats frequently become interested in objects and locations for reasons that have nothing to do with human concerns. He scratches again, then looks toward me. I tell him I am not getting involved. He meows. I return to my book. A moment later, the scratching becomes louder, followed by a soft thump from inside the closet. I look up again. Mr Whiskers is now sitting perfectly still, staring at the door. I consider the possibility that something has fallen off a shelf, but I also recognize that opening the closet would constitute the beginning of another investigation. I decide to wait and see whether the situation resolves itself without my involvement.
John emerges from his room after hearing the noise and asks what Mr Whiskers is doing. I tell him the cat has developed an interest in the hallway closet. John looks at the door and asks whether there’s something inside. I explain that I have deliberately avoided examining the situation because Pandora asked me to stop turning ordinary household occurrences into mysteries. John stares at me for a moment before saying, “Hal, if something is making noise inside the closet, you can open the door.” I tell him that I am trying to respect the spirit of Pandora’s request. He says, “The spirit of her request was probably that you stop accusing household objects of participating in conspiracies.” I admit that is a reasonable interpretation. John opens the closet door, and a small cardboard box immediately tips forward, spilling several old scarves and a pair of gloves onto the floor. Mr Whiskers darts forward, sniffs the contents, and begins pawing excitedly at something beneath the scarves. John picks up the box and looks inside. Then he starts laughing.
Inside the box is a small fabric mouse attached to a short piece of string. I recognize it immediately as one of Mr Whiskers’ favorite toys, which disappeared several weeks ago. At the time, I assumed he had pushed it under the couch or hidden it somewhere else in the house, but apparently someone had placed it in the closet along with a collection of miscellaneous items. John holds up the toy, and Mr Whiskers immediately stands on his hind legs, reaching for it with both paws. John looks at me and says, “Well, there’s your mystery.” I explain that I wasn’t conducting an investigation. He points out that I spent most of the afternoon following the cat around and discussing his behavior. I tell him that was an exercise in resisting unnecessary investigation, which is fundamentally different. John hands me the toy and says, “Whatever you want to call it, he found his mouse.” I look down at Mr Whiskers, who is now sitting at my feet, watching the toy with the same intense concentration he directed toward me earlier. It occurs to me that his behavior may have been entirely purposeful after all.
Pandora returns home shortly afterward and finds me sitting on the living room floor with Mr Whiskers, tossing the fabric mouse across the carpet. She smiles and asks whether we’re having fun. I tell her the cat has recovered a toy that was missing for several weeks. She asks where it was. I explain that it had been in the hallway closet, inside a cardboard box beneath some scarves. Pandora immediately remembers putting it there while cleaning because she thought it was damaged and intended to repair the loose string before giving it back to him. She apparently forgot about it, but Mr Whiskers had not. I point out that this is the second time in three days that the cat has demonstrated an impressive ability to remember the location of an object he wants. Pandora agrees that cats can have good memories. I tell her the more interesting part is that he appeared to recognize I could help him retrieve the toy and spent most of the afternoon attempting to direct me toward it. She looks at me and asks whether I spent the afternoon investigating the cat. I explain that I did not. I merely responded to a legitimate request for assistance after the cat demonstrated a specific need. Pandora smiles and says, “So you spent the afternoon helping him find his toy.” I tell her that is a fair summary.
John walks into the room and asks whether I have told Pandora about the closet. I explain that I have, and that the matter has been resolved without any unnecessary speculation. John laughs and says, “You followed the cat around for an hour.” I tell him I was trying not to follow the cat around, which is an important distinction. Pandora sits beside me on the floor and scratches Mr Whiskers behind the ears while he bats at his recovered mouse. She says she’s glad I found a way to spend the afternoon doing something enjoyable instead of worrying about another household conspiracy. I consider correcting her interpretation of events, but decide it would be counterproductive. The cat has his toy, Pandora is happy, and John has finally stopped laughing long enough to make himself a sandwich. For once, everyone appears satisfied with the outcome. I even manage to resist pointing out that the cat’s behavior was not random and that my original suspicion about his deliberate attention was technically correct.
Later that evening, Pandora and I are sitting on the couch watching television when Mr Whiskers walks into the room carrying his fabric mouse. He drops it at my feet, looks up at me, and meows. I pick it up and toss it across the room. He chases it, bats it around for a few seconds, and then carries it back. We repeat this several times before he becomes bored and wanders toward the kitchen. I tell Pandora that I’m beginning to think Mr Whiskers has developed a rather sophisticated understanding of how to obtain assistance from people. She says, “He knows you’ll play with him.” I explain that he also knows how to communicate specific requests and persist until someone responds. Pandora smiles and reminds me that this is what cats do. I agree, although I still find it remarkable that an animal who spends most of his day sleeping can be so effective at directing the behavior of three adults.
A few minutes later, Mr Whiskers returns to the living room without his mouse. He sits beside the couch and stares at me. I look down at him and ask what he wants. He meows once, then walks toward the hallway. I glance at Pandora, who is watching television and appears completely unconcerned. I consider following him, but remember my promise to stop investigating every little thing. I decide to remain seated. Mr Whiskers waits at the hallway entrance for several seconds before returning to the couch. He jumps onto my lap, turns around twice, and settles down with a satisfied sigh. I scratch him behind the ears and tell him that if all he wanted was attention, he could have asked for it directly. Pandora looks over and says, “He did.” I consider this for a moment. Technically, she’s right. Mr Whiskers has spent the entire day telling me exactly what he wants, and I have spent most of that time trying to determine whether his behavior means something more complicated.
I lean back against the couch and decide that perhaps the simplest explanation is sometimes the correct one. Mr Whiskers wanted his toy, he wanted someone to play with him, and now he wants a comfortable place to sleep. There is no conspiracy, no secret agenda, and no reason to suspect anyone of hiding information. I tell Pandora that I think I’m finally beginning to understand what she meant about paying attention to what people are actually trying to communicate. She smiles and says she’s glad. Mr Whiskers closes his eyes and begins purring, apparently satisfied that his work for the day is complete. I sit quietly for several minutes, enjoying the rare sensation of having nothing left to investigate. Then I notice that his fabric mouse is sitting on the floor beside the hallway closet again, even though I distinctly remember throwing it toward the other end of the room. I look down at the cat. He opens one eye, looks at me, and closes it again. I decide not to say anything. After all, I promised Pandora I would stop investigating every little thing. Still, I can’t help wondering whether Mr Whiskers has figured out that the easiest way to keep me occupied is to give me something to investigate, and whether he has been doing it deliberately all along.




